Discover more from Criticism Is Dead

a weekly podcast about the film, TV, and culture we're consuming and what it all means (if it means anything at all). hosted by @jennygzhang and @onelongpiece

Pachinko, Winning Time, and stacked casts

Fictional and dramatized adaptations of real events, plus Barbie and Oppenheimer casting announcements

Criticism Is Dead

and

Jenny G. Zhang

Apr 19, 2022

Hello!

On this week’s episode of Criticism Is Dead, we discuss Pachinko and Winning Time, two different approaches to retelling history.

Click here to listen to the full episode on the web

Or listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher, Pocket Casts, Google Podcasts, or other podcast apps.

02:32 Pachinko, streaming on Apple TV+, is an eminently watchable drama, but much of its spirit has been lost in the translation from book to screen.

Adaptation is not an easy task: inevitably, things must be altered — some removed, others added — to suit another medium. But we shouldn’t accept it as a given that we will lost so much in an adaptation, either; a few, like Station Eleven (previously discussed here), not only capture the soul of the original, but also manage to stand on their own as rich, original, creative works. The TV version of Pachinko has not quite succeeded on that front, so far — its biggest issue, as New York Times critic Mike Hale writes, is in its “Hollywoodization.” When the series exercises restraint in its emotional peaks, as in the final moments between Sunja and her mother, it achieves real heartfelt beauty. But other scenes feel too engineered, doubling down on wrenching scores and cliché dialogue seemingly in pursuit of making a statement or drawing out tears. It’s a shame, because Pachinko has a lot going for it otherwise: cinematography, acting, costumes, sets, etc.

P.S. Other smart reviews to read: Inkoo Kang in the Washington Post, Shirley Li in The Atlantic.

26:00 HBO’s Winning Time is a self-assured, stylish delight of a show, if you can make it through the scene-setting first few episodes.

The faux archival footage, the film stock, the graphics, the cartoon flourishes, the fourth wall-breaking wink-winks — it’s admittedly a lot, but that’s also part of the fun. There’s a real joie de vivre to this series, a confident swagger that looks and feels different than anything else airing right now. Like Atlanta (previously discussed here), Winning Time is firmly in control of everything it chooses to spend time on, the things it speeds past, and all the (probably plentiful) creative liberties that it takes. This is not a wholly accurate retelling of history, per se, but the kernel of truth — the broader outline of events — remains. What else can we say, it’s fun!